This blog is hosted on Ideas on EuropeIdeas on Europe Avatar

Brexit deal is too complicated for a referendum, says prisons minister

On this week’s BBC Question Time, Prisons Minister, Rory Stewart, said we couldn’t have a new ‘People’s Vote’ on the final Brexit deal because, basically, it’s too complicated for a referendum choice.

When QT presenter, David Dimbleby, asked the minister if the government would put the final Brexit deal to an election, Mr Stewart replied that the Chequers deal “involves 17 different components. It’s not appropriate for a referendum choice.”

So, we were asked a simple question in 2016 on whether or not we should remain a member of the European Union. But now we’re not allowed any say on the complicated answer. How democratic is that?

If the terms of us leaving are too complicated to be decided by a referendum, then the same argument can be applied to the original question of whether we should remain in or leave the EU.

Because the decision about our membership of the EU doesn’t involve just ’17 different components’. It involves tens of thousands of components.

Mr Stewart talked of the Chequers deal as if it is a done deal. But the rest of us know that it’s a dead deal.

Many MPs – both Remainers and Brexiters – say they won’t vote for it. More crucially, the European Union say they won’t accept it.

So what deal will we get? Nobody knows, but a no deal, which would be catastrophic for all our lives, is increasingly looking likely.

We must have a democratic say on this. It’s vital.

The problem is that binary choices don’t work. Not in our own lives, and not in politics.

  • Do you say a simple yes or no to a holiday? No, you also need to know where you’re going, when, and how much.
  • Do you say a simple yes or no to a new job? No, you also need to know what the job entails, the salary, and the conditions of employment.

When we know the actual final details of the Brexit deal or no deal, the electorate needs to have a say on it.

It’s no good giving us a yes or no choice to a complicated question, and then telling us we can’t have any say on the detailed answer.

We need another referendum, or another snap general election.

We cannot allow incompetent government ministers to decide the future of this country, and all our lives, without any further input from us, the people.

Mr Stewart proclaimed on Question Time that:

“If we don’t leave the European Union, there will be a political crisis that will tear this country apart for the next 50 years.”

No, Mr Stewart.

Most of us can now see the exact opposite: leaving the European Union will tear this country apart for the next 50 years.

Give us a say on our future. That’s democratic.

The government’s view is that they can go ahead and decide our future for us, without any say by us.

That’s not democratic. That’s dictatorship.

  • Watch the 90-second video of the Prison Minister saying that the Brexit deal is not appropriate for a referendum choice:

________________________________________________________

  • Join and share the discussion about this article on Facebook:

'Brexit deal is too complicated for a referendum'

→ 1-minute video: Freudian slip by the prisons minister – Please share'FINAL BREXIT DEAL IS TOO COMPLICATED FOR A REFERENDUM'Last night on BBC Question Time, Prisons Minister, Rory Stewart, said we couldn’t have a #PeoplesVote on the final Brexit deal because, basically, it’s too complicated for a referendum choice. When QT presenter, David Dimbleby, asked the minister if the government would put the final Brexit deal to an election, Mr Stewart replied that the Chequers deal “involves 17 different components. It’s not appropriate for a referendum choice.”So, in essence, the referendum was a trick. We were asked a simple question in 2016. But now we’re not allowed any say on the complicated answer.If the terms of us leaving are too complicated to be decided by a referendum, then the same argument can be applied to the original question of whether we should remain in or leave the EU. Because the decision about our membership of the EU doesn’t involve just ’17 different components’. It involves tens of thousands of components.Mr Stewart talked of the Chequers deal as if it is a done deal. But the rest of us know that it’s a dead deal. Many MPs – both Remainers and Brexiters – say they won’t vote for it. More crucially, the European Union say they won’t accept it.So what deal will we get? Nobody knows, but a no deal, which would be catastrophic for all our lives, is increasingly looking likely. We must have a democratic say on this. It's vital.The problem is that binary choices don’t work. Not in our own lives, and not in politics.Do you say a simple yes or no to a holiday? No, you also need to know where you’re going, when, and how much. Do you say a simple yes or no to a new job? No, you also need to know what the job entails, the salary, and the conditions of employment.When we know the actual final details of the Brexit deal or no deal, the electorate needs to have a say on it. It’s no good giving us a yes or no choice to a complicated question, and then telling us we can’t have any say on the detailed answer.We need another referendum, or another snap general election.We cannot allow incompetent government ministers to decide the future of this country, and all our lives, without any further input from us, the people.Mr Stewart proclaimed on Question Time that, “If we don’t leave the European Union, there will be a political crisis that will tear this country apart for the next 50 years.”No, Mr Stewart. Most of us can now see the exact opposite: leaving the European Union will tear this country apart for the next 50 years. Give us a say on our future. That’s democratic. The government’s view is that they can go ahead and decide our future for us, without any say by us.That’s not democratic. That's dictatorship.• Words and video compilation by Jon Danzig• Please re-Tweet, and follow Reasons2Remain on Twitter:twitter.com/Reasons2Remain/status/1040609288090214400• This video is now available on the Reasons2Remain YouTube channel. Please share, and follow our channel. https://youtu.be/kMzoo14K_qI▪ Before commenting on the Reasons2Remain campaign page, please read our new Rules of Engagement: Rules.Reasons2Remain.com********************************************► Watch Jon Danzig's 50-minute video: 'Can Britain Stop Brexit?' Go to CanBritainStopBrexit.com********************************************• To follow and support Reasons2Remain just ‘like’ the page, and please invite all your friends to like the page. ********************************************• Please recommend Reasons2Remain in the reviews section. Here's the link: facebook.com/Reasons2Remain/reviews/********************************************• Follow Reasons2Remain on Twitter: twitter.com/reasons2remain and Instagram: instagram.com/reasons2remain/********************************************• Explore our unique Reasons2Remain gallery of over 1,000 graphics and articles: reasons2remain.co.uk********************************************• Reasons2Remain is an entirely unfunded community campaign, unaffiliated with any other group or political party, and is run entirely by volunteers. If you'd like to help, please send us a private message.********************************************• © Reasons2Remain 2018. All our articles and graphics are the copyright of Reasons2Remain. We only allow sharing using the Facebook share button. Any other use requires our advance permission in writing.#STOPBREXIT #EXITBREXIT #PEOPLESVOTE #FINALSAY

Posted by Reasons2Remain on Friday, 14 September 2018



Comments are closed.

UACES and Ideas on Europe do not take responsibility for opinions expressed in articles on blogs hosted on Ideas on Europe. All opinions are those of the contributing authors.